The Fairytale Fraud Exposed
We all watched the glittering live spectacle. We all saw the tears, the vows, and the expertly produced “romance” of the century. But it turns out, the Golden Bachelor wedding between Gerry Turner and Theresa Nist was built on a throne of lies, panic, and backstage meltdowns. Faith Martin, the finalist who had her heart smashed on national television, has finally broken her silence, and she is torching the entire narrative.
In a shocking admission that exposes the dark underbelly of the reality TV machine, Faith revealed she came dangerously close to pulling a full Hollywood objection on live TV. Speaking on the Friday, January episode of iHeartRadio’s Almost Famous OG podcast, Faith didn’t just spill tea; she spilled the entire toxic potion. She admitted that while the cameras were rolling and the world was weeping with joy, she was sitting in the pews contemplating blowing the entire production sky-high.
“That night, I really contemplated being the one that stands up at the wedding and objects,” Faith confessed. “Can you imagine? I wanted to do it so badly.”
Why would she want to ruin the big day? Because she knew the secret that nobody else did: Gerry Turner did not want to get married.
The Secret Midnight Confession
Here is where the story shifts from “jealous ex” to “whistleblower.” Faith revealed that she managed to slip away from the prying eyes of producers to have a private, off-the-record conversation with Gerry shortly before the ceremony. What he told her changes everything we thought we knew about the Golden Bachelor.
According to Faith, the -year-old groom wasn’t nervous; he was trying to escape. She claims Gerry explicitly told her he was having massive regrets and felt completely trapped by the machinery of the show.
“He was like, ‘I don’t want to do it. I don’t want to do it,'” Faith recalled him saying. Let that sink in. The man standing at the altar in front of millions of viewers was allegedly begging for an exit strategy behind closed doors.
Gerry reportedly told her, “I think I got too wrapped up in the moment, and I don’t think I should do it.”
So why did he walk down that aisle? Why did he drag Theresa Nist into a marriage that was dead on arrival? According to Faith, Gerry felt he had no choice. “He goes, ‘I made my bed. I did this to myself. I got to do it,'” she stated.
“I got to do it.” That is not the language of love. That is the language of a man terrified of breach of contract lawsuits and public humiliation. Faith, to her credit, tried to be the voice of reason in the middle of the insanity. “I’m like, ‘No, you don’t, and you should tell Theresa, and she’s probably feeling the same way,'” she told him.
But the machine was already in motion. The guests were seated, the cameras were live, and Gerry Turner put on his suit and played the part, knowing full well it was a disaster waiting to happen.
The Producer Factor: Ratings Gold Or PR Nightmare?
Faith’s admission raises a massive question about the producers’ role in this debacle. She mentioned on the podcast that she hesitated to object because she “thought my producer would kill me.” But let’s be real—this is the Bachelor
Podcast host and franchise veteran Trista Sutter pointed out the obvious: “They also would have been like, ‘Well, this is a moment.'”
Imagine the ratings if Faith had stood up and screamed, “He doesn’t love you!” It would have been the most viral moment in television history. But fear kept her seated. Instead of a dramatic objection, we got a “perfect” wedding that crumbled into a divorce announcement on Good Morning America just three months later.
Faith’s silence allowed the charade to continue, but at what cost? She admits the guilt and the knowledge of the truth ate her alive during the festivities.
RELATED: Faith Martin on ‘Perplexing’ Dynamic With Theresa Nist and Gerry Turner
Sleepless Nights And A “Disturbing” Reality
While the rest of the world was celebrating “finding love at any age,” Faith Martin was living in a psychological horror movie. She revealed she didn’t sleep for four days while attending the Golden Wedding in Palm Springs.
“I was trashed because I knew way too much,” she admitted. “I sat up in bed not being able to sleep, and I went, ‘Oh, my God, I am living a soap opera on a TV show, but it’s the real soap opera that nobody knows about that is far more disturbing than the little soap opera that I’m in.'”
She called the reality “disturbing.” That is a heavy word. It implies that what we saw on screen was a sanitized, manufactured lie designed to sell ads, while real human emotions were being ground into dust backstage.
Remember those shots of Faith crying during the ceremony? The producers framed it as bittersweet tears of a woman happy for her ex. Wrong.
“I’m crying because the man I love is marrying a woman that I’m not so sure he loves yet telling her that he loves her,” Faith said, dropping the hammer on Gerry’s integrity. “And knowing Theresa well enough to know this is never going to work between the two.”
She was watching a car crash in slow motion, and she was the only one who saw the wall coming.
Gerry’s “Trapped” Narrative vs. Theresa’s Clapback
Faith isn’t the only one talking. Gerry has been trying to rewrite history to make himself look like a tragic victim of circumstance. In his book The Golden Years—released in November because of course he wrote a book—he confirmed speaking to Faith and feeling “trapped.”
“I felt like I was doing the right thing. I just didn’t feel overjoyed about it,” Gerry told reporters in a cover story, trying to spin his cold feet as normal jitters. “I had second thoughts, but I don’t think [they] were exaggerated from anyone’s normal second thoughts.”
Suspicious behavior alert: Telling your ex-girlfriend “I don’t want to do it” the night before the wedding is not “normal second thoughts.” That is a cry for help.
Theresa Nist, the woman who was humiliated publicly by this three-month marriage, isn’t buying Gerry’s “poor me” act. In a statement that was polite but laced with venom, she fired back.
“It makes me very sad to think that he felt empty and trapped. I wish he had said something and just ended it,” Theresa stated. Then she delivered the kill shot: “But at least now I understand why he was so hurtful to me so many times. And I will say this. Those in glass houses should not throw stones.”
Theresa is implying that Gerry’s behavior behind closed doors was “hurtful” and that his public persona doesn’t match the man she lived with. The divorce wasn’t just about distance; it was about deception.
Faith Plays The Middle Man
Despite dropping these bombshells, Faith is trying to play Switzerland in this war. She claims she sees both sides, but her revelations clearly paint Gerry as a man who valued his reputation over his honesty.
“I hear Theresa and how she talks about it. I hear Gary and how he talks about it,” Faith explained. “I think both are honestly telling their truth… I love them both, and I think they’re both right.”
It is a diplomatic answer, but the damage is done. By revealing Gerry’s pre-wedding confession, she has validated every critic who said this relationship was fake from the jump. Gerry didn’t marry Theresa because of destiny; he married her because he “made his bed” and the cameras were on.
What Else Is Being Hidden?
This revelation cracks the door open on the entire Golden Bachelor franchise. If the “purest” version of the show was this manipulated and toxic, what is happening on the regular seasons? Faith Martin stayed silent for nearly two years, likely under the threat of NDAs and producer pressure.
Now that the floodgates are open, we have to wonder: What else did Gerry say that night? Did he confess feelings for Faith? Did he admit it was all for the fame?
The “Golden” sheen has officially rubbed off, revealing a rusty, jagged mess underneath. Gerry Turner walked down that aisle with a smile on his face and a lie in his heart, and Faith Martin watched it happen. The only question left is whether Theresa will sue for fraud now that she knows her groom was looking for the exit sign before the ceremony even started.
This soap opera isn’t over yet.
RELATED: Golden Bachelor’s Gerry Turner Compares Theresa Nist Wedding to a ‘Funeral’
