NCIS’ Original MCRT Team Members Ranked

NCIS has become a staple of television, and when talking about its impact, it’s not possible not to mention the original Major Case Response Team and the characters we will never forget. Leroy Jethro Gibbs, Abby Sciuto, Tony DiNozzo, Dr. Ducky Mallard, and Kate Todd have shaped NCIS into what it is today, each adding their unique touch to the show’s dynamic. While their shoes have been properly filled after their departures, their legacy continues to live on in the hearts of viewers.

As NCIS grew in popularity, ultimately becoming one of the longest-running series in the history of television, it branched out into five spinoff series. From NCIS: Los Angeles to NCIS: Hawaiʻi, the franchise’s impact on modern TV is undeniable. Plus, with an upcoming Tony & Ziva show finding its place in the NCIS timeline, the story continues with even more on the horizon.

5 Kate Todd

Played by Sasha Alexander

NCIS Sasha Alexander's Caitlin %22Kate%22 Todd looking skeptical

NCIS Sasha Alexander's Caitlin Todd looking concerned

NCIS Sasha Alexander's Kate Todd laying down on Air Force One

Sasha Alexander as Kate Todd facing another woman in the NCIS bullpen on NCIS

A close up of Kate Todd in a lingerie police outfit in NCIS

Etched into our brains for the rest of time, Caitlin Todd’s shocking death in the second season of NCIS was perhaps the biggest bombshell twist in the entire series. In reality, Sasha Alexander, the actor who played Kate, couldn’t handle the workload, which is why her character had to be written off the show. Unfortunately, because of her shorter run, we never got to see Kate grow.

Still, Kate was a highly skilled investigator who was often the voice of reason among the original MCRT team. Her compassion set her apart, making her both relatable and easy to love, which is also one of the main reasons her untimely death took most by surprise. The event echoed throughout the rest of NCIS' time on air, marking a turning point that forever changed the dynamics of the show. Despite her time being cut short, we will always remember Kate fondly.

4 Dr. Ducky Mallard

Played by David McCallum

Ducky looking perplexed in NCIS autopsy

Ducky looked shocked in NCIS

Ducky looking surprised in NCIS Kepp Going

Ducky speaking at a lecture in NCIS season 15

Ducky looking at Gibbs' watch in NCIS

Watching the late David McCallum play the brilliant Dr. Donald "Ducky" Mallard at times felt like seeing the actor play himself. Ducky was one of NCIS’ most beloved characters, and, at the time of his passing in 2023, was the last remaining member of the original MCRT team. However, Ducky was so much more than a medical examiner. He was a pillar of wisdom, stability, and humanity who brought us some of the best NCIS moments of all time.

Known for his patience, compassion, and long-winded anecdotes, Ducky delivered some of the best quotes from NCIS. His “I told you so” moments were more often than not laced with humor and warmth, and the combination of dry wit and genuine care made him truly unforgettable. While he might not have been the most central to the plot, Ducky helped define NCIS’ legacy.

3 Tony DiNozzo

Played by Michael Weatherly

Michael Weatherly as Tony DiNozzo smiling sheepishly in the NCIS episode Kill Ari

Michael Weatherly as Tony DiNozzo in NCIS

Michael Weatherly as Tony DiNozzo wearing sunglasses and speaking loudly in NCIS

Michael Weatherly as Tony DiNozzo in a gray suit in NCIS

Tony DiNozzo thinking with his hand raised to his mouth in NCIS

When one thinks of charm, there’s no other NCIS character that comes to mind other than Anthony DiNozzo. Portrayed by Michael Weatherly, DiNozzo mostly went by Tony and stole our hearts along the way. He brought laughter and movie trivia to the original MCRT team like no other, as well as some serious moves with the ladies.

However, despite his suave nature, DiNozzo had some of the most growth seen throughout the series. He went from serial womanizer to having one woman in his life (well, technically, two), which is one of the main reasons we can’t wait for the NCIS: Tony & Ziva spinoff to hit the screen. Tony shared amazing chemistry with almost every team member and, despite having a silly streak, was one of NCIS’ best investigators. Weatherly left the show in 2016 after 13 seasons, but we’ll be seeing him again soon.

2 Abby Sciuto

Played by Pauley Perrette

Abby looking at Ducky in the lab in NCIS

Abby Sciuto smiling and looking off-screen in NCIS

Mark Harmon as Gibbs and Pauley Perrett as Abby in NCIS

Abby looking pensive in NCIS Keep Going

Abby Sciuto sitting in a chair reading a magazine in NCIS season 1

Forensic specialist Abby Sciuto had as much of an impact on NCIS as any other field agent, if not more at times. Her unique personality and quirky brilliance make her one of the most iconic characters of the entire franchise to date, making it no surprise that her departure in season 15 left a palpable void in the show.

Masterfully played by Pauley Perrette, Abby stood out for a number of reasons. Her signature gothic look was a stark contrast to her bubbly personality and made her visually unique in the world of crime investigations. Not only that, but the way Abby approached her work (with the mandatory Caf-Pow in hand) was impressive. She was both intuitive and knowledgeable, all while making forensic science seem exciting. If you ask us, it’s the perfect time for Abby to return to NCIS and bring back her quintessential charm.

1 Leroy Jethro Gibbs

Played by Mark Harmon

Mark Harmon in a close up as Leroy Jethro Gibbs in NCIS-1

Mark Harmon as Gibbs in NCIS

Mark Harmon as Leroy Jethro Gibbs in NCIS

Mark Harmon as Leroy Jethro Gibbs in NCIS

Mark Harmon as Gibbs in NCIS

If there’s one character who is central to the success of NCIS, it’s its fearless and intuitive leader, Leroy Jethro Gibbs. While a few actors have played Gibbs throughout the NCIS franchise, Mark Harmon will go down in history as the man who truly brought him to life. Harmon carried the show for most of the 18 seasons he starred in, and broke our hearts when he decided to leave the MCRT team.

NCIS Franchise Shows

IMDb Rating

NCIS

7.8 / 10

NCIS: Los Angeles

6.8 / 10

NCIS: New Orleans

6.8 / 10

NCIS: Hawaiʻi

6.8 / 10

NCIS: Sydney

5.9 / 10

NCIS: Origins

7.3 / 10

There’s no doubt about it — Gibbs' presence shaped NCIS from its inception. From his signature personality, boat building, and infamous slaps on the head to nailing down some of the show's most notorious villains and continuously standing up for what’s right, Gibbs’ legacy remains unsurpassed. Even after leaving the show in 2021, his presence continues to be deeply felt, proving just how much Gibbs was and continues to be the heart and soul of NCIS.

Related Posts

NCIS: Sydney Season 2, Episode 4 Review: Teenage Angst Waters Down a Technothriller

NCIS: Sydney Season 2, Episode 4, "Truth Sabre," wants to be the kind of technothriller that audiences loved in the 1990s. All the components are there: lots…

Jimmy Interrogates His Daughter in New ‘NCIS’ Season 22, Episode 14 Sneak Peek

Jimmy Palmer (Brian Dietzen) is hellbent on solving the case of a mysterious bag of money his daughter found behind a naval library. In NCIS Season 22,…

NCIS Season 22, Episode 14 Review: Jimmy Palmer Stars in a Lightweight Mystery

NCIS Season 22, Episode 14, "Close to Home" is an episode that viewers will enjoy, but forget shortly after it's over. The CBS show serves up another…

“We Have Some Really Wonderful Actors In Mind”: ‘NCIS’ Star Teases Dream Pairing For Torres and Palmer [Exclusive]

Now that NCIS has officially been renewed for Season 23, fans might have a clue about one storyline that could be featured soon. NCIS Season 22, Episode…

Michael Weatherly Has ‘NCIS’ Fans in a Frenzy Over His Thrilling Spinoff Update

Heads up, NCIS fans — we just got the best news about one of our favorite duos returning to TV. Back in February 2024, fans learned Michael…

Pauley Perrette pictured with bangs and jet-black hair in must-see photo as she calls back to alter-ego Abby Sciutto

Pauley Perrette just took fans on a trip down memory lane. Though these days, the retired actress' signature hair is more of a rainbow look with multicolor…